Baking can sometimes call for shortening, but what if there’s none in the cupboard? Many people face this issue, especially when a craving strikes. There are several great substitutes for shortening that can work just as well in recipes.
Butter is a favourite replacement and can add a rich flavour. Vegetable oil is another option that helps keep baked goods moist. Even ingredients like applesauce or Greek yoghurt can be used, depending on what you’re baking.
Experimenting with these alternatives can lead to delicious results. Choosing the right substitute can change the texture and taste, giving treats a unique twist.
Substitutes for Vegetable Shortening
There are several good substitutes for vegetable shortening when baking. Options like butter, margarine, and lard can offer similar textures and flavours in recipes. Each option has its characteristics that can affect the final product.
Butter
Butter is a popular choice for replacing vegetable shortening. It gives a rich flavour and a tender texture to baked goods. When using butter, it is best to use unsalted butter, as it allows for more control over the salt content in the recipe.
A common substitution ratio is 1:1, meaning you can use the same amount of butter as shortening. The moisture content in butter (about 15-20% water) might slightly change the texture, making baked goods richer and more flavourful. Baking times may need to be adjusted, so keep an eye on the oven.
Margarine
Margarine can also work well as a substitute for vegetable shortening. It has a similar fat content, which helps achieve a comparable texture. When selecting margarine, choosing one that has a higher fat content is best, as this mimics shortening more closely.
Like butter, the substitution ratio is 1:1. Margarine often contains water, which can influence the texture. It may not offer the same depth of flavour as butter, but it does keep baked goods moist.
Lard
Lard is a less common substitute, but it can be very effective. It is 100% fat and can create flaky textures in baked goods like pie crusts. Lard has a neutral flavour, which can be an advantage in recipes where you want the other flavours to shine.
The substitution ratio is usually 1:1 as well. It’s important to choose a good quality lard, preferably from a reputable source. Lard can enhance the texture and keep things tender without adding a strong taste.
Plant-Based Substitutes
Plant-based substitutes can be great options for shortening in baking. They offer different flavours and textures, making baked goods delicious and healthier.
Coconut Oil
Coconut oil is a popular choice for those looking for a plant-based option. It has a rich flavour and a smooth consistency. When used in baking, it gives a light, fluffy texture.
To substitute coconut oil for shortening, use a 1:1 ratio. For instance, if a recipe calls for 100 grams of shortening, replace it with 100 grams of coconut oil.
Coconut oil works well in cookies and cakes. It melts easily, making it perfect for recipes that require melted fat.
It’s also dairy-free and contains healthy fats, which can be a plus for some diets.
Apple Sauce
Apple sauce is another great substitute. It adds moisture and sweetness to baked goods without adding a lot of fat. This makes it a healthier choice compared to traditional shortening.
When using apple sauce, replace half the amount of shortening with apple sauce. For example, if the recipe calls for 100 grams of shortening, use 50 grams of shortening and 50 grams of apple sauce.
Apple sauce is perfect for muffins and quick breads. It keeps them soft and moist. Plus, it’s easy to find and usually less expensive.
Using apple sauce gives baked goods a subtle apple flavour, which can be a nice touch in some recipes.
Mashed Avocado
Mashed avocado is a surprising but effective alternative to shortening. It adds creaminess and a healthy dose of fats to baked goods.
To use avocado, simply mash it and substitute it in equal parts for shortening. For instance, if a recipe needs 100 grams of shortening, use 100 grams of mashed avocado.
The avocado works wonderfully in brownies and cakes. It makes them rich and moist while adding nutrients.
Keep in mind that mashed avocado can change the colour and flavour slightly, so it’s best used in recipes where these changes won’t be an issue.
Healthier Alternatives
Bakers can swap out shortening for some healthier options that still deliver great results. Here are three popular substitutes that can enhance recipes while offering a more nutritious profile.
Greek Yoghurt
Greek yoghurt is a fantastic alternative. It adds moisture and a slight tanginess to baked goods. It contains protein, which helps to make recipes richer.
When using Greek yoghurt, it’s best to replace shortening with half the amount needed. For example, if a recipe calls for 1 cup of shortening, use ½ cup of Greek yoghurt. This swap works well in muffins, cakes, and quick breads.
Just bear in mind that Greek yoghurt can make the texture slightly denser. However, it works well for recipes that benefit from a moist outcome.
Puréed Fruits
Puréed fruits are a sweet and simple option. They can add natural sugars and moisture to baked treats. Good choices include applesauce, mashed bananas, or pumpkin purée.
To replace shortening, the general rule is to use the same amount of purée as shortening. So, 1 cup of shortening could be replaced with 1 cup of puréed fruit.
This option is perfect for brownies, cakes, and pancakes. The result is a slightly fruity flavour that enhances sweetness without needing extra sugar.
Nut Butters
Nut butter, like almond or peanut butter, provides healthy fats and added flavour. They can help bring a rich, nutty taste to various recipes.
When using nut butter, replace shortening with about ¾ of the amount. For instance, if a recipe calls for 1 cup of shortening, start with ¾ cup of nut butter.
This swap works great in cookies, bars, and cakes. The result is a deliciously creamy texture with the added benefit of protein and fibre.
Non-Fat Substitutes
Many bakers look for ways to reduce fat in their recipes while still achieving a tasty result. Non-fat substitutes like applesauce and banana purée can help maintain moisture and flavour without the added calories.
Applesauce for Fat Reduction
Applesauce is a popular choice for replacing fat in baking. It adds moisture and sweetness, making it ideal for cakes, muffins, and quick breads. To use applesauce as a substitute, replace half of the fat in the recipe with an equal amount of applesauce.
For example, if a recipe calls for 1 cup of butter, using ½ cup of butter and ½ cup of applesauce works well. This swap works best in recipes where the texture isn’t too reliant on fat, such as brownies or pancakes.
When using applesauce, it’s important to monitor the baking time. Products with applesauce may bake faster, so checking for doneness a bit earlier is a good idea.
Banana Purée
Banana purée is another excellent non-fat substitute. It brings a natural sweetness and moistness to baked goods. Just like applesauce, bakers can use banana purée to replace half of the fat in a recipe.
For instance, in a recipe requiring 1 cup of oil, ½ cup of oil and ½ cup of banana purée will work well. This substitution is especially tasty in breads, muffins, and pancakes.
There are a couple of things to keep in mind. The stronger banana flavour may not suit all recipes, especially those with delicate flavours. Adjust sweetness if necessary, as bananas add extra sugar to the mix.
Also, Read
Adjustments for Substituting Shortening
When swapping out shortening in baking recipes, there are a few important adjustments to consider. It’s essential to think about moisture, baking times, and sugar content to ensure the final product is delicious.
Changes in Moisture Content
Different substitutes can change the moisture level in baked goods. For example, butter has a higher water content than shortening. This can lead to a wetter dough or batter.
To balance moisture, it’s a good idea to reduce any added liquid ingredients. If using butter instead of shortening, consider using 15% less liquid.
Some substitutes, like coconut oil, can affect texture. Keep that in mind when deciding on the right amount to use. Adjusting these liquids helps keep the bake just right.
Altering Baking Times and Temperatures
When the type of fat changes, baking times and temperatures might need to shift. Butter and other oils might bake a bit quicker due to their different properties.
If using butter, check for doneness a few minutes earlier than the recipe suggests. When using coconut oil, it may require lower temperatures.
Generally, it’s smart to reduce the temperature by about 10-15 degrees Celsius. This helps prevent the edges from browning too fast while allowing the centre to cook properly.
Modifying Sugar Ratios
Sugar levels might need tweaking as well. Different fats can interact with sugar differently. For example, shortening often adds moisture but doesn’t caramelise like butter.
If replacing shortening with butter, consider reducing sugar slightly. Cutting sugar by about 10% can help prevent excess browning.
When using oils, the change in sweetness can also call for adjustments. It’s all about finding the right balance to make sure the flavour hits home.